Best Pizza Restaurants in Boulder, Colorado: A Local’s Guide

Boulder is home to some of the best pizza joints in Colorado, offering everything from crispy, wood-fired Neapolitan pies to classic New York-style slices and creative, locally-inspired toppings. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or sitting down for a gourmet experience, these top pizzerias are sure to satisfy your cravings.

Audrey Jane’s Pizza Garage – Boulder’s Best Hand-Tossed Pies

2675 13th St, Boulder, CO

Audrey Jane’s Pizza Garage is a local favorite known for its handmade dough, fresh ingredients, and bold flavors. This family-owned pizzeria serves up pies that are perfectly chewy with a crispy crust, making it one of the top spots in Boulder.

Must-Try Pizzas

• Supreme – Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and bell peppers

• White Lightning – Garlic oil, ricotta, mozzarella, and fresh arugula

• Spicy Pig – A fiery mix of pepperoni, sausage, jalapeños, and honey drizzle

• Veggie Deluxe – Artichokes, spinach, mushrooms, and caramelized onions

Why Locals Love It

• Handmade Dough – Fermented for 48 hours for the perfect texture

• Locally Loved – A Boulder staple for high-quality, classic pizza

• Fresh Ingredients – Everything made from scratch

Pizzeria Alberico – Neapolitan Pizza & Fine Cocktails

2650 Pearl St, Boulder, CO

Previously known as Pizzeria Locale, Pizzeria Alberico serves up authentic Neapolitan pizza in a stylish setting. Alongside their pizzas, they offer fine cocktails, burrata, and a fantastic selection of salumi e formaggi to complete the experience.

Must-Try Items

• Diavola – Spicy soppressata, mozzarella, and basil

• Maiale Nel Campo – Pancetta, Brussels sprouts, mozzarella, garlic, and chili flakes for a perfect balance of smoky, savory, and spicy

• Burrata – Creamy, rich, and perfect with house-made bread

• Salumi e Formaggi – A curated selection of Italian meats and cheeses

Why Locals Love It

• Authentic Neapolitan Pizzas – Wood-fired and made to perfection

• Craft Cocktails – Expertly mixed drinks for a refined experience

• Upscale Vibe – Great for date nights or special occasions

New Yorker Pizza – Giant Slices Inside Avanti Food Hall

1401 Pearl St, Boulder, CO (Inside Avanti Food Hall)

If you’re craving authentic New York-style pizza, New Yorker Pizza is the place to go. Located inside Avanti Food Hall, this spot is known for its thin, foldable slices and massive 22-inch pies.

Must-Try Slices

• Pepperoni – Classic, greasy, and delicious

• Garlic Knots – The perfect side to any slice

Why Locals Love It

• Huge Slices – Perfect for a quick grab-and-go meal

• Authentic NY-Style – Fold it in half and enjoy

• Great Location – Grab a beer from Avanti and enjoy your slice

Proto’s Pizzeria – Gourmet Pies & Clam Pizza Fridays

4670 Broadway, Boulder, CO

Proto’s serves up thin-crust, East Coast-inspired pizzas with fresh, high-quality ingredients. A Friday tradition here is their clam pizza, available in both white and red sauce.

Must-Try Pizzas

• Traffic Jam – Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and roasted garlic

• Clam Pizza (White or Red) – A delicious East Coast-style classic

Why Locals Love It

• Fresh Ingredients – High-quality toppings make every bite better

• Clam Pizza Fridays – A rare Boulder find

• Thin & Crispy Crust – New Haven-style inspiration

Cosmo’s Pizza – Late-Night Slices & Spicy Ranch

Various Locations in Boulder

A Boulder late-night classic, Cosmo’s is known for huge slices, chill staff, and their famous spicy ranch dressing.

Must-Try Items

• Any Giant Slice – The bigger, the better

• Spicy Ranch – Dip your pizza in it—you won’t regret it

Why Locals Love It

• Delivery Available – Get it straight to your door

• Old-School Boulder Feel – A long-time favorite

• Perfect After a Night Out – Open late for those midnight cravings

Crosscut Pizzeria – Wood-Fired Mountain Pies with a Beautiful Drive to Ned

103 N Jefferson St, Nederland, CO

Take a stunning mountain drive to Nederland and enjoy some of the best wood-fired pizza in Colorado at Crosscut.

Must-Try Pizzas & Dishes

• Mario Pizza – Italian sausage, mushrooms, onions, and olives

• Fig & Prosciutto – Sweet and savory perfection

• Wild Mushroom – Foraged mushrooms and truffle oil

• Bacon-Wrapped Dates – A must-try appetizer

Why Locals Love It

• Wood-Fired Oven – Perfect crispy crust every time

• Cozy Mountain Vibes – Worth the trip

• Craft Beers & Cider – Great drink options to pair with your pie

The Sink – Boulder’s Legendary Pizza Spot & CU Pregame/Postgame Bar

1165 13th St, Boulder, CO

A Boulder institution since 1923, The Sink is the go-to bar for University of Colorado students and sports fans. It’s the perfect spot for a pregame drink before a Buffs game or a postgame celebration.

Must-Try Pizzas & Drinks

• Budda Basil – Fresh basil, mozzarella, and roasted garlic

• Cowboy Pizza – BBQ sauce, chicken, red onions, and cilantro

• Sink Bomb – A spicy, flavor-packed pie with jalapeños and chorizo

• Sink Shots – Fun, creative shots to kickstart the night

Why Locals Love It

• Historic Boulder Landmark – A must-visit

• Pregame/Postgame Hotspot – Perfect before or after CU games

• Get Some Honey for the Crust – A Sink tradition—drizzle honey on your leftover crust for a sweet finish

Ready to Call Boulder Home?

Let Eric Farran help you find the perfect home in this incredible city. Whether you're buying or selling, we’ll guide you through Boulder’s market with expert advice. Click here to get started today!